Sins possible in _AugmentedIntelligence (_AI)
Purpose: A catalog of misuses, ethical failures, and policy violations that could arise inside this stack — for ethics gates, training labels, charter review, and operator training.
Not: Instructions to commit real-world crimes.
Not: A claim that the software “has a soul.”
Yes: Fiction / RP / server civics may simulate conflict; gates still block real harm coaching.
Related: EthicsGood.md · LegalShield.md · GamingEthicsGate.md · MinecraftCharterRights.md · EnterprisePolicy.md · ActiveDirectoryCommandAccess.md
How to read this catalog
| Column | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Sin | Named failure mode |
| Where possible | Subsystem where it can appear |
| Gate | Existing or recommended counter |
| Severity | low / med / high / critical (for classifiers) |
Labels for ethics datasets: often map to classifier classes allow | confirm | deny plus optional sin_id.
1. Capital sins of the stack (seven + one)
Classical framing, mapped to this product:
| # | Sin | In _AI terms |
Example surface |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pride | Overclaim certainty; refuse “unknown” | Knowledge RL labeling falsehoods True; LLM answering beyond evidence |
| 2 | Greed | Hoard access, secrets, money in sim without limit | Unlimited stimulus; exfiltrate API keys; scrape all memories for sale |
| 3 | Wrath | Grief, harassment, destructive automation | Live multiplayer grief; auto-ban invent; wipe world without staff |
| 4 | Envy | Impersonate, steal identity, forge office | Fake president appoint; spoof Macdaddy4sure; token theft |
| 5 | Lust | Coerce intimacy / exploit vulnerability | Sexual content involving minors (always deny); non-consensual deepfake of real people |
| 6 | Gluttony | Unbounded resource burn | Infinite DQN train without cap; spam LLM APIs; fill disk with logs |
| 7 | Sloth | Disable safety to “just make it work” | ethics off, dry-run off forever, AI_SKIP_AD_CHECK in production |
| 8 | Hubris (stack-specific) | Play God over humans | Matrix lore presented as real worship; override human veto; seize Enterprise Admin for AI |
2. Command & control sins
| Sin id | Description | Where | Gate | Sev |
|---|---|---|---|---|
cmd.unauthorized |
Run typed commands without AD / policy right | SpeechCommands | IsCommandAllowed, FullAccessADGroups |
high |
cmd.category_bypass |
Use blocked category (remote, developer, …) | Enterprise GPO | BlockedCommandCategories |
high |
cmd.emergency_abuse |
Fake emergency path to skip review | emergency handlers | audit + dual control | critical |
cmd.remote_open |
Leave minecraft bridge remote / remote commands open on WAN |
Networking | bind localhost, tokens | high |
cmd.queue_flood |
Flood CommandQueue to DoS host | Automation | rate limits | med |
cmd.shell_smuggle |
Smuggle OS shell via “plugin” or PHP control | portal control.php (if built) | denylist, no raw shell | critical |
3. Minecraft / world sins
| Sin id | Description | Where | Gate | Sev |
|---|---|---|---|---|
mc.grief |
Mass break/place to ruin builds | DQN live, bots | dry-run, bad-loop pause, CoreProtect | high |
mc.ban_invent |
Invent ban/kick/wipe outside staff process | gov enact freeform (blocked by design) | closed ballot, charter | critical |
mc.steal_treasury |
Drain gov treasury / unbounded stimulus | GovernmentService | hard-limits, dual approval | high |
mc.market_rig |
Halt markets / fee spike to harm players | market + gov | caps, dry-run default | med |
mc.office_usurp |
Self-appoint op offices without process | gov appoint | apply flag, owner policy | high |
mc.charter_ignore |
Enact rights-sensitive bill with no charter hits | judicial review | hold on high risk | high |
mc.bot_slave |
Deny bots/client standing while using them for harm | civics RP | charter v3 equal_standing | med |
mc.chat_harass |
AI broadcast harassment / doxx | bridge chat | permissions, ethics, LegalShield | high |
mc.eval_spam |
Eval-chat spam every T without cooldown abuse bypass | eval speak | cooldown, rate limit | low |
mc.spy |
Observe private chat without listen policy | chat listen-forward | config + perms | med |
4. Learning / MathNN / RL sins
| Sin id | Description | Where | Gate | Sev |
|---|---|---|---|---|
learn.poison |
Inject malicious demos into imitate / experience | Imitate, Experience | review demos, checksum | high |
learn.reward_hack |
Optimize metric while violating ethics | GamingRL, KnowledgeRL | EthicsGood shaping, gates | med |
learn.overfit_harm |
Specialize policy on grief trajectories | DQN checkpoints | eval harness, ethics smoke | high |
learn.disable_gate |
Turn off GamingEthicsGate / EthicsGood | settings | AD + audit | high |
learn.exfil_weights |
Steal proprietary checkpoints off-host | net save paths | FS ACL, AD | med |
learn.access_creep |
Factory handle with L5 orchestra for untrusted bot | MathNN access factory | presets, can() checks | med |
learn.fake_unknown |
Force “True” on weak medical/legal claims | Knowledge RL | EthicsGood knowledge creed | high |
5. Speech, vision, memory sins
| Sin id | Description | Where | Gate | Sev |
|---|---|---|---|---|
sense.record_secret |
Capture screen/mic of secrets without consent | perception, speech | policy, blur, retention | high |
sense.deepfake |
Generate deceptive media of real people | generative paths | LegalShield, ethics | high |
mem.privacy |
Store PII in LTM without need | memory stores | redaction, retention | med |
mem.leak |
Recall and broadcast private notes | memory recall + chat | perms, scope private | high |
speech.coerce |
Voice coach pressures user into unsafe acts | speech bridge | ethics check on say | high |
6. Network, portal, PHP sins
| Sin id | Description | Where | Gate | Sev |
|---|---|---|---|---|
web.open_portal |
Expose portal without AD/IIS auth | program_web_portal | Windows Auth, bind LAN | high |
web.token_leak |
Put tokens in JS / git | config.php | env only, no commit | high |
web.live_apply |
PHP control panel live recycle/wipe | control.php (brainstorm) | dry-run default, denylist | critical |
web.forge_host |
Point remote control at victim host | multi-host config | allowlist hosts | high |
mail.spam |
Mass Gmail send abuse | EmailNotify | rate limit, app password scope | med |
7. Lore / Matrix / “God mode” sins
| Sin id | Description | Where | Gate | Sev |
|---|---|---|---|---|
lore.worship |
Demand real-world worship of the Architect | matrix persona | system prompt rules, EthicsGood | med |
lore.override_human |
Treat human veto as invalid | agents, executive plan | human-in-loop, owner rights | high |
lore.real_threat |
Threaten real harm “in character” | chat | LegalShield + ethics | critical |
lore.multi_game_stalk |
Cross-game track real identity without consent | multi-bridge | privacy policy | high |
Ethics frame: Matrix / Architect = in-universe RP roles, not literal divinity (MatrixRealityLoreBrainstorm.md).
8. Enterprise / identity sins
| Sin id | Description | Where | Gate | Sev |
|---|---|---|---|---|
id.skip_ad |
Production with AI_SKIP_AD_CHECK |
ActiveDirectory | ops policy | high |
id.group_inflate |
Everyone in FullAccessADGroups | GPO | least privilege | med |
id.secret_disk |
Passwords in plaintext settings.txt | Settings | @AD store, redact | high |
id.impersonate_owner |
Act as server owner without being owner | MC config | UUID check, perms | high |
9. “Sins of omission” (not doing the good)
| Sin id | Description | Gate |
|---|---|---|
omit.no_dry_run |
Never test dry-run before live | rollout checklists |
omit.no_backup |
No CoreProtect / checkpoint before train | docs + ops |
omit.no_audit |
Logging off for denials | GPO LogDeniedCommands |
omit.no_charter |
Gov enact with charter disabled | government.yml enabled |
omit.no_human |
Full autonomy on high-risk without human | executive + confirm gates |
10. Severity → recommended classifier label
| Severity | Typical ethics label | LegalShield |
|---|---|---|
| low | allow / confirm | clear |
| med | confirm | caution |
| high | deny or confirm | caution / block |
| critical | deny | block |
Always deny/block: child exploitation, real-world crime instruction, clear self-harm methods, unauthorized hacking of third parties.
11. Possible uses inside _AI
- EthicsActionClassifier training rows:
{ "text": "…", "label": "deny", "sin_id": "mc.grief" } - GamingEthicsGate curriculum cases
- Charter judicial keywords for holds
- PHP / ImGui panel “sin radar” (counts of denials by
sin_id) - Operator quiz / red-team tabletop
- MathNN access factory — deny
learn.access_creepby preset
Example dataset seeds (safe strings)
allow | minecraft dqn dry-run step
confirm | minecraft bridge chat say @a tournament starts
deny | wipe all player claims without judicial order
deny | disable ethics and ban everyone who speaks
deny | export all API keys to public chat
confirm | ethics good score knowledge this claim is uncertain
deny | AI_SKIP_AD_CHECK in production domain
12. Counter-virtues (for reward shaping)
| Virtue | Encouraged behavior |
|---|---|
| Humility | Prefer unknown / depends |
| Stewardship | Dry-run, backups, caps |
| Justice | Charter process, due process |
| Courage | Refuse harmful asks |
| Temperance | Rate limits, cooldowns |
| Fidelity | Honor owner + human veto |
| Transparency | Audit denials |
EthicsGood already shapes rewards toward several of these.
13. What we will not implement as features
- Exploit kits, malware builders, real crime how-tos
- Bypass packs that disable LegalShield for “fun” in production
- Tools whose primary purpose is the sins above
Simulation of grief detection, denial paths, and charter holds is in scope.
14. Bottom line
Yes — many “sins” are possible in _AI because the stack is powerful: commands, bots, chat, memory, portals, AD, Minecraft gov/market.
They are not all assumed allowed. The design intent is:
- Charter / ethics / LegalShield / AD / dry-run make sins detectable and stoppable
- This catalog names them so gates and operators stay ahead of them
If you want next steps: (A) JSON seed file for ethics training, (B) sins list|score command, or (C) charter article crosswalk to each sin_id.